Newswire

Newswire

border-bottom-line-min

Interior gate not required for freight elevator under Code in 1923; Court dismisses Complaint for injuries suffered on manually operated freight elevator

February 26, 2020

William Romero v. Waterfront N.Y., et al, 19852/2009 ((Sup.Ct. Kings Cty. 2016) In a twenty-seven page decision, Justice David B. Vaughan granted summary judgment, dismissing a personal injury Complaint by an elevator operator, in its entirety. Plaintiff sustained substantial injuries to his foot and ankle in a freight elevator in a building owned by, or…

Read More

Defects and shortcomings in submissions from plaintiff’s chiropractor; Summary Judgment granted for defendant on serious injury threshold

February 26, 2020

Thomas v. Crittenden, 2016 WL 6138392 (Sup.Ct. Bronx Cty. 2016) A Bronx court has granted defendant’s motion for summary judgment dismissing Plaintiff’s complaint for failure to satisfy the serious injury threshold under Insurance Law section 5102(d), based upon defendant’s Neurologist’s neurological examination and a report on an MRI of the lumbar spine. Defendant successfully argued…

Read More

No extension of time for Plaintiff to effect service due to failure to exercise due diligence; Court dismisses auto-accident complaint

February 26, 2020

Nancly Jean-Pierre v. Roderick Crawford, Index No. 308139/2012 (Sup.Ct. Bronx Cty. October 4, 2013) Purported service of process at a location in the Bronx, nearly three years after a traffic accident, was improper, where the defendant established he was, in fact, a resident of Brooklyn. Acting Supreme Court Justice Julia I. Rodriguez dismissed the Complaint…

Read More

Apportionment of Loss clause questions certified to New York Court of Appeals

February 26, 2020

Quaker Hills v. Pacific Indemnity, 11-3670 (2nd Cir. Aug. 29, 2013) In a case with potentially far-reaching implications relating to the right to limit property insurance coverage, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit has certified three questions to the New York Court of Appeals. The case involves a total loss by…

Read More

Negligent disposal of video evidence not sufficient to warrant striking of defendant’s answer; Appellate Division modifies with adverse inference charge

February 26, 2020

Peters v Hernandez, 142 AD3d 980, 2016 NY Slip Op 05983 (2nd Dep’t 2016) An interesting decision from a state appellate court sets limits under the spoliation doctrine regarding the appropriate sanction for losing video evidence. Something more than negligence is needed for a court to strike a pleading when the moving party has not…

Read More

James M. Brown, Esq.

February 26, 2020

We are pleased to announce that James M. Brown, Esq., has joined Abrams Gorelick. Mr. Brown joins the Construction Law, General Liability, and Products Liability groups. Mr. Brown has extensive experience in the construction law field, focusing on the application of New York’s Labor Law as it applies to owners, general contractors, construction managers, and…

Read More

Physical limitations and their duration unsupported by objective proof; defendant driver entitled to summary judgment on serious injury threshold

February 26, 2020

Sook Hee Park v. Young O. Park and Michael Papadakis, Index No. 310492/2009 (Sup. Ct. Bronx Cty., May 21, 2013) Click on this link to view additional information in pdf format The Honorable Ben R. Barbato issued a Decision and Order granting summary judgment dismissing the Summons and Complaint of the plaintiff on the grounds…

Read More

No waiver of privilege over appraiser’s report; Appellate Division reverses Order compelling disclosure

February 26, 2020

915 2nd Pub Inc. d/b/a Thady Con’s Bar & Restaurant, et al. v. QBE Insurance Corporation, 2013 NY Slip Op 04748 (1st Dep’t 2013) A single notation in a claim file that an expert’s report was sent to plaintiffs’ prior counsel is insufficient to show waiver of privilege over an appraisal report prepared by an…

Read More

Testimony concerning building violations at defendant’s premises insufficient to defeat motion for summary judgment by out-of-possession landlord

February 26, 2020

Joseph v. Emmis Communications d/b/a Hot 97.1 FM, et al., Index No. 20843/2010 (Sup. Ct. Bronx Ct. April 19, 2013) Plaintiff’s reference to deposition testimony concerning building violations was not sufficient to raise a triable issue of fact, held a Bronx Court. The defendant moved for summary judgment upon its defense that, as an out-of-possession…

Read More

Abrams Gorelick team continues streak in defeating “serious injury” claims in Bronx auto cases

February 26, 2020

Ross v. Arroyo, Supreme Court, Bronx County, Index No. 309161/2010 A Decision and Order of the Honorable Justice Ben A. Barbato extended a string of successes for Abrams Gorelick Partner Irwin Miller and Associate Dennis Monaco, in cases involving claims of “serious injury” resulting from auto accidents. The Court granted summary judgment holding that the…

Read More